Under contract-accepting backup offers. Welcome to this beautifully renovated Lincolnville cottage, where historic charm meets modern peace of mind. This fully furnished 2-bed, 1-bath home has been thoughtfully updated and is ready to serve as a primary residence, vacation retreat, or income-generating short-term rental. The inviting covered front porch (with gutters) sets the stage for morning coffee or evening conversation while keeping deliveries dry. Step inside to an open, light-filled living space and a chef-inspired kitchen boasting quartz countertops, soft-close cabinetry, farmhouse sink, custom pantry, and stainless-steel appliances including a French-door refrigerator, Fisher Paykel dishwasher drawer, and air-fryer range. The split bedroom layout offers privacy, while the stylish bath features granite finishes, a custom glass barn-door shower, and preserved Carrara marble flooring. Recent upgrades provide comfort and confidence: a durable metal roof with more than 27 years of life remaining, 200-amp electrical panel (2021), HVAC (2016), full plumbing re-pipe, water heater (2021), and a newly built front porch with gutters. Inside and out, every major component has been cared for. The oversized one-car garage includes laundry, water softener, and room for storage or larger vehicles. A newly built 8×12 powered shed expands the possibilities, ideal as a home office, creative studio, or guest overflow. Entertain outdoors on the back deck overlooking the spacious fenced yard with fire-pit. Zoned RS-2, this home offers flexibility for its next owner. Beyond the property, you’re immersed in the best of St. Augustine—the nation’s oldest city. Walk to historic downtown shops, restaurants, and cultural sites, or enjoy nearby parks, trails, and the community recreation center with pool, playground, and ball fields. Freedom Park, just blocks away, offers 10+ acres of green space along the San Sebastian River with picnic areas and a meditation garden. From history and culture to convenience and modern updates, this Lincolnville gem captures it all. All information provided is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Property Details
Price:
$440,000
MLS #:
FC312840
Status:
Pending
Beds:
2
Baths:
1
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Subdivision:
BUENA ESPERANZA SUB
Neighborhood:
32084saintaugustine
Listed Date:
Sep 22, 2025
Finished Sq Ft:
729
Total Sq Ft:
1,341
Lot Size:
5,227 sqft / 0.12 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1956
See this Listing
Schools
Middle School:
SEBASTIAN MIDDLE SCHOOL
High School:
St. Augustine High School
Interior
Appliances
Dishwasher, Dryer, Range, Refrigerator, Washer, Water Softener
Bathrooms
1 Full Bathroom
Cooling
Central Air
Flooring
Other, Hardwood
Heating
Central, Electric
Interior Features
Ceiling Fan(s)
Laundry Features
In Garage
Levels
One
Exterior
Attached Garage YN
1
Construction Materials
Cement Siding, Wood Frame
Covered Spaces
1
Direction Faces
East
Exterior Features
Outdoor Shower
Fencing
Wood
Garage Spaces
1
Roof
Metal
Financial
Tax Year
2024
Taxes
$6,223
Map
Community
- Address172 MARTIN LUTHER KING AVENUE ST AUGUSTINE FL
- SubdivisionBUENA ESPERANZA SUB
- CityST AUGUSTINE
- CountySt Johns
- Zip Code32084
Subdivisions in ST AUGUSTINE
- AFRO AMERICAN SUB
- ANASTASIA OAKS
- ANDALUSIA
- ANTONIO HUERTAS GRANT SUB
- ARBOR MILL PH 1-B
- AVILA AT PALENCIA
- BAYVIEW
- BEACH HOMES/VLGS/VILANO
- BEACON LAKE
- BEACON LAKE PH 2A
- BEACON LAKE PH 3B
- BELLE HAVEN
- BIERA MAR
- BLACKMOOR GATE/ROYAL ST AUGUST
- BRIDGEWATER
- BRIDGEWATER PH 1A
- CASCADES/WORLD GOLF VILLAGE
- CEDAR RDG
- CLARK ADD
- CLARK ADDITION
- CLARK SUB
- CLEARLAKE/MARSH LNDG
- COLEE SUB
- COLEE SUBDIVISION
- COLLEGE PARK INSTITUTE
- COMMODORES CLUB PH 1B
- CONQUISTADOR CONDO
- CONQUISTADOR CONDO APTS/ST AUG
- COQUINA GABLES EAST
- CORDERA
- CORONADO REP
- COTTAGES AT WINDING CREEK
- CREEKSIDE/TWIN CRKS-PH 2B
- CRESCENT COVE
- CRESCENT KEY PH 2
- CRESTON HOUSE CONDO
- CYPRESS BAY
- DAVID SHRS
- DAVIS ACRES TWO
- DAVIS SHORES
- DAVIS SHORES OCEAN VIEW
- DEEP CRK LNDG PH 2
- EAGLE CRK/ST AUGUSTINE
- ENTRADA
- ENTRADA PH 2 UN 4
- FLORIDA CLUB BLDG 625
- FLORIDA CLUB CONDO
- FULLERWOOD PARK SUB
- GENOVAR ADD
- GLEN ST JOHNS PH 2B
- GRAN LAKE PH 1A
- GRAND OAKS PH 1D
- HEARTWOOD
- HERITAGE PARK PRCL E-1
- HIBISCUS 02
- HIDEAWAY/OLD MOULTRIE
- ISLAND HOUSE
- ISLAND VILLAS
- JOHNS CREEK
- KEITH SUB
- LAKEWOOD POINTE
- LAS CALINAS
- LINDA MAR SUB
- MADEIRA HEIGHTS
- MANTANZAS INLET BEACH
- MARINERS WATCH CONDO
- MARSH CREEK, UNIT TWO
- MEADOW RIDGE
- MICKLERS
- MICKLERS SUB
- MIRAMAR
- MODEL LAND CO SUB
- MOULTRIE OAKS
- NIGHTINGALE GLEN
- NORTHRIDGE LAKES
- OCEAN GALLERY VISTAS PACIFICA
- OCEAN VILLAS CONDO
- ORCHARD PARK
- OSEOLA ACRES
- PALENCIA
- PALOMA
- PALOMA SUB
- PARK RIDGE
- PARKLAND PRESERVE PH 4B
- PINEHURST POINTE
- PINES
- PONCE DE LEON HGTS LOTS
- PORPOISE POINT
- PORPOISE PT
- PRAIRIE CRK 03
- PRAIRIE LAKES PH 2
- PRESERVE/BANNON LKS PH 2D
- QUAIL HOL/OCN SOUTH BLDG A-1
- QUAIL HOLLOW ON THE OCEAN SOUTH
- QUAIL HOLLOW/OCEAN SOUTH
- QUAIL HOLLOW/THE OCEAN SOUTH
- RACEY ACRES 130
- RAND OAKS PH 1D
- RAVENSWOOD
- ROCK SPGS FARMS
- RS GARNETT SUB
- SAINT JOHNS SIX MILE CREEK NORTH UNIT 1
- SAINT JOHNS SIX MILE CREEK NORTH UNIT 5
- SAND DOLLAR 03
- SCHALLERS
- SEAGROVE ST AUGUSTINE BCH
- SEASCAPE
- SEBASTIAN COVE
- SEVILLA/WORLD COMMERCE PH 02
- SHEARWATER PH 3A-2
- SHEARWATER PHASE 2C
- SILVER LNDG
- SIX MILE CREEK WEST
- SOUTH HAMPTON UNIT 5
- ST AUGUSTINE
- ST AUGUSTINE HEIGHTS
- ST AUGUSTINE PARK
- ST AUGUSTINE SHORES
- ST AUGUSTINE SHRS 08
- ST AUGUSTINE SOUTH
- ST AUGUSTINE SOUTH UN 10
- ST JOHNS SIX MILE CREEK NORTH UNIT 1
- ST JOHNS SIX MILE CREEK NORTH UT 3
- SUMMER ISLAND
- SUMMER ISLAND PH I
- SUMMERHAVEN
- SUMMERHOUSE 02 BCH & RACQUET C
- SUMMERHOUSE 03 BEACH & RACQU
- SUMMERHOUSE 04 BCH & RACQUET C
- SUMMERHOUSE I BCH & RACQUET CL
- SUMMERHOUSE I BEACH & RACQUET
- SUMMERHOUSE III BCH & RACQUET CLUB CONDO
- SUNSET HARBOR
- SUNSET HARBOR CONDO
- SURFWOOD SUB
- THE COQUINA
- THE LOFTS AT SEBASTIAN COVE
- TRAILMARK
- TREASURE BCH 2ND ADD
- TREASURE BCH 3RD ADD
- TREATY OAKS
- TRESTLE BAY
- VILANO BEACH
- VILLA SAN MARCO CONDO
- VILLAGES OF SELOY CONDOS
- VILLAGES OF VALENCIA PH 5
- VILLAGES/SELOY BLDG 322
- VILLAGES/VALENCIA PH 02A & 03A
- WHISPERING CRK
- WHISPERING OAKS
- WILDWOOD ESTATES
- WILDWOOD PARK
- WILLIAMS ADD
- WINDSWEPT ACRES
- WINDWARD RANCH
- WINDWARD RANCH PH 10
- WINDWARD RANCH PH 9
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in ST AUGUSTINE as of May 05, 2026
94
Single Family Listed
94
Avg DOM
337
Avg $ / SqFt
$765,341
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the BUENA ESPERANZA SUB subdivision, 172 MARTIN LUTHER KING AVENUE ST AUGUSTINE FL is a Single Family for sale in ST AUGUSTINE, FL, 32084. It is listed for $440,000 and features 2 beds, 1 baths, and has approximately 729 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1956. The current price per square foot is $604. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in ST AUGUSTINE is $337. The average listing price for Single Family in ST AUGUSTINE is $765,341. To schedule a showing of MLS#fc312840 at 172 MARTIN LUTHER KING AVENUE in ST AUGUSTINE, FL, contact your CENTURY 21 Carioti agent at 800-783-8847.
Similar Listings Nearby
Courtesy of SIMPLY REAL ESTATE. Disclaimer: All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Orlando/Tampa – FL. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than CENTURY 21 Carioti include the name of the listing broker. Neither the listing company nor CENTURY 21 Carioti shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. Copyright 2026. Orlando/Tampa – FL. All rights reserved. 172 MARTIN LUTHER KING AVENUE
ST AUGUSTINE, FL
