Under contract-accepting backup offers. $100,000 UNDER APPRAISED VALUE! Elegant and sophisticated aptly describes this pristine 1927 Historic Landmark pool home with a Carriage House situated on over a 1/4 acre lot in the highly sought after Downtown Dunedin golf cart friendly Fenway-on-the-Bay neighborhood. This stylish home is for the discerning buyer with every attention to detail being addressed. Built in the same era, and within walking distance of the iconic Fenway Hotel, this home has been meticulously renovated with high-end modern luxuries while retaining its era charm. The main home boasts a welcoming living room with gas fireplace, dining room, family room, and a large renovated kitchen with striking granite countertops, a huge kitchen island, farm sink, wood shaker cabinetry, high-end commercial Wolf & Subzero stainless-steel appliances, and a 100+ bottle wine cooler. Off of the kitchen is a charming Butler’s pantry with copper sink, vintage window, built-in shelving and more spacious cabinetry. Open to the kitchen enjoy the family room, featuring its original refinished oak floor and unique raised ceilings and unparalleled view of the pool and backyard. The primary bedroom is spacious and bright and offers a built-in closet plus modern extra tall cabinet storage space. The second bedroom is currently being used as an office and it too offers a built-in closet. The pristine primary bathroom has a frameless glass shower surround, vintage-look vanity, lighted mirror, modern tiled floor, and a Vela Plus Self-Cleaning Smart Toilet/Bidet. Off of the dining room is an intimate bespoke cocktail lounge with lighted built ins, mirror shelving and deep storage cabinets, which could be transformed into an office. The home boasts wide wood plank and distinctive tile flooring, a neutral color palette, unique lighting fixtures, ample storage, all culminating into a truly historic feel with modern, luxurious updates. The fenced backyard is lush, private and offers a view of St Joseph’s Sound and a tranquil 15×30 natural gas pebble tec, heated pool and spill over 8-person spa. There is a cabana with electricity and windows, currently used as a work shed. This backyard oasis is awesome and has been the scene of many events and festivities. The meticulous detail & size of this backyard oasis can only be appreciated in person. The light and bright Carriage House is separate from the main home and shares similar high-end finishes, with its tall ceilings, large tiled bathroom, a kitchenette, and spacious, sunny living area and bedroom offering a beachy vibe with ceiling fans, a 2 head mini-split a/c, painted wood flooring, & shiplap wall accents. This stunningly beautiful home is move-in ready and offers many notable efficient and structural features including LOW-E impact windows, whole house Generac generator, encapsulated crawl space, and a UV air purification system. With a home of this vintage, it is refreshing to see the renovations have been permitted through the City of Dunedin. Watch the attached VIDEO to fully appreciate this home. The location is also first class; walk or jump in your golf cart to nearby shops and restaurants; the Pinellas Trail intersects the street and is just a stroll away. Watch the sunset from your own exquisite backyard, or head downtown for dinner or to the many festivals and events. Couple this with excellent schools, pristine beaches and all that fabulous Dunedin has to offer, and you have the ultimate elegant Florida lifestyle home!
Property Details
Price:
$1,650,000
MLS #:
TB8428221
Status:
Pending
Beds:
3
Baths:
2.5
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Subdivision:
FENWAY-ON-THE-BAY
Neighborhood:
34698dunedin
Listed Date:
Nov 12, 2025
Finished Sq Ft:
2,243
Total Sq Ft:
2,243
Lot Size:
15,503 sqft / 0.36 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1927
See this Listing
Schools
Elementary School:
Dunedin Elementary-PN
Middle School:
Dunedin Highland Middle-PN
High School:
Dunedin High-PN
Interior
Appliances
Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Freezer, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator, Tankless Water Heater, Washer, Wine Refrigerator
Bathrooms
2 Full Bathrooms, 1 Half Bathroom
Cooling
Central Air
Flooring
Ceramic Tile, Slate, Hardwood
Heating
Electric
Interior Features
Built-in Features, Ceiling Fan(s), Crown Molding, Dry Bar, Eating Space In Kitchen, High Ceilings, Kitchen/Family Room Combo, Open Floorplan, Solid Wood Cabinets, Stone Counters, Window Treatments
Laundry Features
Inside, Laundry Room
Levels
One
Exterior
Architectural Style
Mediterranean
Construction Materials
Stucco
Direction Faces
North
Exterior Features
Irrigation System, Lighting, Sliding Doors, Sprinkler Metered, Storage
Fencing
Wood
Green Energy Efficient
Windows
Patio And Porch Features
Front Porch, Patio
Roof
Shingle
Spa Features
Heated, In Ground
Window Features
Storm Window(s)
Financial
Tax Year
2024
Taxes
$12,194
Map
Community
- Address225 PRESIDENT STREET DUNEDIN FL
- SubdivisionFENWAY-ON-THE-BAY
- CityDUNEDIN
- CountyPinellas
- Zip Code34698
Subdivisions in DUNEDIN
- A & B RANCHETTE
- ACREAGE
- AMBERGLEN
- ANDREWS SUB C S
- AQUA SOLIS
- ARTIST COLONY OF DUNEDIN CONDO
- BARRINGTON HILLS
- BAYWOOD SHORES
- BAYWOOD SHORES 1ST ADD
- BELLE TERRE
- BRAE-MOOR SOUTH
- BROADWAY ADD RESUB
- CARDINAL MANOR 2ND ADD
- CEDAR CREEK MOBILE HOME PARK UNREC
- COACHLIGHT WAY
- COASTAL HIGHLANDS
- COCONUT VILLAS OF DUNEDIN CONDO
- COLONIAL ACRES
- COLONIAL VILLAGE
- CONCORD ARMS CONDO
- CONCORD GROVES
- COUNTRY LAKES I CONDO
- COUNTRYGROVE WEST
- COVERED BRIDGE TWNHMS
- CURLEW LANDINGS
- CURLEW LANDINGS UNIT 2
- DEXTER PARK
- DEXTER PARK 1ST ADD
- DOLPHIN POINTE OF DUNEDIN CONDO
- DOUGLAS ARMS
- DUNALTA
- DUNEDIN
- DUNEDIN CAUSEWAY CENTER
- DUNEDIN COVE
- DUNEDIN CSWY CENTER
- DUNEDIN ISLES 1
- DUNEDIN ISLES ADD
- DUNEDIN ISLES COUNTRY CLUB
- DUNEDIN ISLES COUNTRY CLUB SEC A
- DUNEDIN ISLES ESTATE
- DUNEDIN ISLES ESTATES 1ST ADD
- DUNEDIN LAKEWOOD ESTATES
- DUNEDIN LAKEWOOD ESTATES 1ST ADD
- DUNEDIN LAKEWOOD ESTATES 3RD ADD
- DUNEDIN MANOR 1ST ADD
- DUNEDIN PALMS UNREC
- DUNEDIN PINES
- DUNEDIN TOWN OF
- EDGEWATER ARMS
- EDGEWATER ARMS 1ST CONDO
- EDGEWATER ARMS 3RD CONDO
- EDGEWATER ARMS 4TH CONDO
- FAIRWAY ESTATES 1ST ADD
- FAIRWAY ESTATES 2ND ADD
- FAIRWAY ESTATES 4TH ADD
- FAIRWAY HEIGHTS
- FAIRWAY MANOR
- FENWAY ON THE BAY
- FENWAY-ON-THE-BAY
- FOREST PARK CONDO
- GLYNWOOD HIGHLANDS
- GOLDEN ACRES MOBILE HOME PARK UNREC
- GREENWAY MANOR
- GROVE ACRES
- GROVE ACRES 2ND ADD
- GROVE ACRES 3RD ADD
- GROVE TERRACE
- GROVEWOOD OF DUNEDIN
- GUY ROY L SUB
- HARBOR POINTE CONDO
- HARBOR POINTE WEST CONDO
- HARBOR VIEW VILLAS
- HARBOR VIEW VILLAS 1ST ADD
- HARBOR VIEW VILLAS 1ST ADD LOT 112
- HARBOR VIEW VILLAS 2ND ADD
- HARBOR VIEW VILLAS 4TH ADD
- HARBOR VILLAS AT DUNEDIN
- HARBOUR OAKS OF DUNEDIN CONDO
- HEATHER HILL APTS
- HEATHER LAKE APTS CONDO
- HEATHER RIDGE
- HEATHERWOOD PLACE
- HELLERS SUB
- HIGHLAND ESTATES
- HIGHLAND PARK 1ST ADD
- HIGHLAND TOWNHOMES
- HIGHLAND WOODS 2
- HIGHLAND WOODS 3
- HUNTERS GLEN CONDO
- IDLEWILD ESTATES
- ISLAND BAY TWNHS CONDO
- ISLAND PARK CONDO
- ISLAND TOWERS
- KING ARTHURS COURT CONDO
- LAKE HEATHER HEIGHTS
- LAKE HIGHLANDER MOBILE HOME PARK UNREC
- LAKE TIFFANY CONDO
- LAKESIDE TERRACE 1ST ADD
- LAKESIDE TERRACE SUB
- LOCH LOMOND ESTATES CONDO
- LOCKLIE SUB
- LOFTY PINE ESTATES 1ST ADD
- MALONES L H SUB
- MARINA TOWER A CONDO
- MARSHALL E A
- MEDITERRANEAN MANORS
- MEDITERRANEAN MANORS UNIT 9 CONDO
- MIRA VISTA TWNHMS PH II
- MOORES M W SUB
- NEW ATHENS CITY 1ST ADD
- NIGELS SUB
- OAK BEND TWNHMS
- OAK LAKE HEIGHTS
- OAKLAND SUB
- OAKLAND SUB 2
- OSPREY PLACE
- PARK SUB GEO W
- PATRICIA ESTATES
- PATRICIAN OAKS
- PINEHURST HIGHLANDS
- PINEHURST MEADOW
- PINEHURST MEADOW ADD
- PINEHURST VILLAGE
- PIPERS GLEN
- PLEASANT GROVE PARK
- PLEASANT GROVE PARK 1ST ADD
- PLEASANT VIEW TERRACE
- PLEASANT VIEW TERRACE 2ND ADD
- PLEASANT VIEW TERRACE 3RD ADD
- PLEASANT VIEW TERRACE 4TH ADD
- PROFESSIONAL CENTER CONDO THE
- RANCHWOOD ESTATES
- RAVENWOOD MANOR
- RESERVE AT MEDITERRANEAN MANORS CONDO
- ROYAL STEWART ARMS
- ROYAL YACHT CLUB NORTH CONDO
- SAILWINDS A CONDO MOTEL THE
- SAN CHRISTOPHER VILLAS
- SAN RUFFINO CONDO
- SAN RUFFINO II CONDO
- SCOTS LANDING
- SCOTSDALE
- SCOTSDALE BLUFFS PH I
- SCOTSDALE VILLA CONDO
- SHADY GROVE TWNHMS
- SHERWOOD FOREST SUB
- SHORE CREST
- SIMPSON & WIFES ADD
- SKYE LOCH VILLAS UNREC
- SOUTH PAULA POINT CONDO
- SPANISH PINES
- SPANISH PINES 2ND ADD
- SPANISH TRAILS
- ST ANDREWS LINKS GOLF CLUB
- STIRLING HEIGHTS
- SUEMAR SUB
- SUEMAR SUB 1ST ADD
- SUNNY RIDGE
- SUNSET BEAUTIFUL
- TAHITIAN PLACE
- TALBOTS SUB
- THRASHER’S TOWNHOUSE
- TOWNHOMES AT HIGHLAND CROSSING
- TOWNHOMES AT WEATHERSFIELD
- TRAILS WEST
- UNION PARK VILLAS UNREC
- VICTORIA PALMS CONDO
- VICTORIA PLACE CONDO
- VICTORIA THE CONDO
- VILLAS BY THE TRAIL
- VILLAS OF FOREST PARK CONDO
- VIRGINIA CROSSING
- VIRGINIA PARK
- WEATHERSFIELD SUB
- WELLINGTON PLACE TWNHS
- WESTWIND I & II RESIDENT OWNED COMMUNITY UNREC
- WEYBRIDGE WOODS
- WEYBRIDGE WOODS-UNIT C
- WHITMIRES W S
- WILLOW WOOD VILLAGE
- WILSHIRE ESTATES
- WILSHIRE ESTATES II
- WILSHIRE ESTATES II SECOND SEC
- WINCHESTER PARK
- WINCHESTER PARK NORTH
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in DUNEDIN as of May 09, 2026
214
Single Family Listed
88
Avg DOM
396
Avg $ / SqFt
$767,844
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the FENWAY-ON-THE-BAY subdivision, 225 PRESIDENT STREET DUNEDIN FL is a Single Family for sale in DUNEDIN, FL, 34698. It is listed for $1,650,000 and features 3 beds, 3 baths, and has approximately 2,243 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1927. The current price per square foot is $736. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in DUNEDIN is $396. The average listing price for Single Family in DUNEDIN is $767,844. To schedule a showing of MLS#tb8428221 at 225 PRESIDENT STREET in DUNEDIN, FL, contact your CENTURY 21 Carioti agent at 800-783-8847.
Similar Listings Nearby
Courtesy of COASTAL PROPERTIES GROUP INTERNATIONAL. Disclaimer: All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Orlando/Tampa – FL. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than CENTURY 21 Carioti include the name of the listing broker. Neither the listing company nor CENTURY 21 Carioti shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. Copyright 2026. Orlando/Tampa – FL. All rights reserved. 225 PRESIDENT STREET
DUNEDIN, FL
